When it comes to luxurious, indulgent fragrances, Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental and Black Phantom By Kilian are two heavyweights in the niche perfume world. Both are known for their rich, complex compositions and opulent appeal. But how do they stack up? We’ve compared them across essential categories—sillage, longevity, compliments, price, and more—to help you choose the perfect fragrance for your collection. Plus, we’ve included links to purchase these exquisite scents!
1. Sillage
- Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental: 90%
- Black Phantom by Kilian: 85%
Both fragrances boast strong sillage, but Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental leaves a slightly more pronounced trail. Its warm, spicy, and gourmand notes make it ideal for grand occasions where you want to be noticed. Black Phantom, while still impressive, has a slightly softer presence, with a smooth, rum-infused sweetness that feels more intimate.
2. Bottle Design
- Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental: 95%
- Black Phantom by Kilian: 90%
Clive Christian bottles are known for their iconic crown design and intricate details, and E Gourmande Oriental is no exception. It’s a true work of art, exuding royalty and sophistication. Black Phantom’s sleek black and gold bottle design is equally striking but leans toward modern luxury rather than regal elegance.
3. Price
- Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental: 60% (Higher price point)
- Black Phantom by Kilian: 70% (More affordable)
Price is a significant differentiator. Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental is priced in the ultra-luxury segment, making it an investment for collectors. In comparison, Black Phantom is still premium but more accessible, offering incredible value for its quality.
4. Longevity
- Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental: 95%
- Black Phantom by Kilian: 90%
Both fragrances are long-lasting, easily staying on the skin for 8–12 hours. However, Clive Christian takes the lead with its stronger base notes of amber, gourmand accords, and spice, which linger for hours after application.
5. Compliments
- Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental: 85%
- Black Phantom by Kilian: 90%
Black Phantom is a crowd-pleaser, with its sweet notes of dark chocolate, coffee, and rum creating an irresistible allure. Clive Christian, on the other hand, is more sophisticated and appeals to niche fragrance enthusiasts, making it slightly less universally loved but deeply admired by those who appreciate high art in perfumery.
6. Projection
- Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental: 90%
- Black Phantom by Kilian: 85%
When it comes to projection, Clive Christian has a more powerful reach, perfect for formal events and evenings where you want to make a grand impression. Black Phantom, while slightly subtler, still offers great projection but leans more toward close encounters.
7. Versatility
- Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental: 80%
- Black Phantom by Kilian: 85%
Black Phantom is more versatile, working well in both casual and formal settings, as well as day or night. Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental is best suited for special occasions, evening wear, and cooler seasons, where its complex and rich profile can truly shine.
8. Overall
- Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental: 88%
- Black Phantom by Kilian: 87%
Both fragrances are exquisite, offering unique experiences. Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental stands out with its regal bottle, rich longevity, and bold sillage, while Black Phantom by Kilian wins in versatility, compliments, and affordability.
Which One Should You Choose?
- Choose Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental if you want a bold, regal fragrance that exudes sophistication and makes a statement. Perfect for collectors and those seeking the ultimate luxury experience.
- Choose Black Phantom by Kilian if you prefer a sweeter, more approachable scent with a modern edge. It’s versatile, seductive, and a bit easier on the wallet.
Ready to Own These Luxury Fragrances? Buy Now!
- Buy Clive Christian E Gourmande Oriental – Add a regal masterpiece to your collection and experience the pinnacle of luxury. Shop here.
- Buy Black Phantom by Kilian – Indulge in sweet, dark elegance with this seductive fragrance. Shop here.
Both fragrances are extraordinary choices for anyone who appreciates high-end perfumery. Whether you’re drawn to the rich complexity of Clive Christian or the sweet allure of Black Phantom, you can’t go wrong with either. Treat yourself to the luxury you deserve!
