In the realm of luxury perfumery, two fragrances stand out for their masterful portrayal of the rose: La Fille de Berlin vs Rose Tonnerre (formerly known as Une Rose). Both scents offer unique interpretations of this timeless bloom, captivating enthusiasts worldwide. This comprehensive comparison delves into their compositions, performance metrics, and overall appeal to guide you in selecting the fragrance that resonates most with your olfactory preferences.
1. Introduction to the Fragrances
- La Fille de Berlin by Serge Lutens: Introduced in 2013, this unisex fragrance is celebrated for its oriental floral character, with the rose at its heart.
- Rose Tonnerre by Frédéric Malle: Originally launched as Une Rose in 2003, this scent was rebranded to Rose Tonnerre. It offers a deep, dark, and earthy rose experience, often described as the rose that vampires would wear.
2. Olfactory Composition
- La Fille de Berlin:
- Top Notes: Rose and Geranium.Heart Notes: Palmarosa.Base Notes: Honey, Moss, and Patchouli.
- Rose Tonnerre:
- Dominant Note: Dark, velvety rose.Accents: Earthy nuances, often associated with truffle and castoreum, though some users report not detecting these notes.
3. Performance Metrics
- Sillage:
- La Fille de Berlin: Moderate sillage, creating an intimate aura around the wearer.
- Rose Tonnerre: Strong sillage, leaving a pronounced scent trail. citeturn0search6
- Longevity:
- La Fille de Berlin: Moderate longevity, lasting several hours on the skin.
- Rose Tonnerre: Long-lasting, with the scent persisting throughout the day.
- Projection:
- La Fille de Berlin: Moderate projection, noticeable within close proximity.
- Rose Tonnerre: Strong projection, making its presence known in a room.
4. Bottle Design
- La Fille de Berlin: Features a sleek, minimalist design with a deep red hue, reflecting the passionate nature of the fragrance.
- Rose Tonnerre: Encased in Frédéric Malle’s signature elegant bottle, exuding sophistication and timelessness.
5. Pricing
- La Fille de Berlin: Approximately €120 for a 50ml bottle.
- Rose Tonnerre: Approximately €150 for a 50ml bottle, reflecting its premium positioning.
6. User Feedback
- La Fille de Berlin: Users appreciate its rich rose scent with hints of overripe blackberries, though some find its longevity moderate.
- Rose Tonnerre: Praised for its deep, dark, and earthy rose aroma, with strong sillage and longevity.
7. Versatility
- La Fille de Berlin: Suitable for both casual and formal settings, ideal for those seeking a refined rose scent.
- Rose Tonnerre: Best suited for evening wear or special occasions, given its bold and intense profile.
8. Overall Impression
- La Fille de Berlin: A sophisticated and elegant rose fragrance, perfect for those who appreciate subtlety and grace.
- Rose Tonnerre: A bold and intense rose scent, ideal for individuals seeking a statement fragrance with depth and character.
9. Purchasing Options
- La Fille de Berlin: Available at Serge Lutens boutiques, authorized retailers, and online platforms.
- Rose Tonnerre: Offered at Frédéric Malle boutiques, select department stores, and the official Frédéric Malle website.
10. Conclusion
Both La Fille de Berlin and Rose Tonnerre offer unique and captivating interpretations of the rose. Your choice between the two will depend on your personal preferences for scent profile, performance, and occasion. Sampling both fragrances is recommended to determine which aligns best with your olfactory desires.
Buy Now
- La Fille de Berlin: Purchase Here
- Rose Tonnerre: Purchase Here
